Rohnert Park's pizza landscape reflects the town's unpretentious spirit. While this college town doesn't chase trends, it delivers solid, satisfying pies that keep locals coming back.
These five spots represent the best of Rohnert Park's pizza scene, from family-run institutions to beloved chains. Each serves the kind of honest food this down-to-earth community craves.
📍 All 5 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- Tony's of North Beach — North Beach Nostalgia
- Mary’s Pizza Shack – Rohnert Park — Wine Country Classic
- Mountain Mike's Pizza — Mountain-Sized Portions
- Mountain Mike's Pizza — Consistent Crowd-Pleaser
- Pizza Guys — Late-Night Champion
1. Tony's of North Beach
✨ Best for: North Beach Nostalgia
📍 Rohnert Park · ⭐ 3.6 · 587 reviews · $$
Tony's brings San Francisco's North Beach vibe to suburban Rohnert Park with thin-crust pies that actually have some snap to them. The pepperoni curls up into perfect little grease cups, and their Italian sausage has enough fennel to make you forget you're eating in a strip mall. College students mix with longtime locals at the worn wooden tables, everyone united by affordable prices and generous portions that stretch across multiple meals.
Must-Order:
Pepperoni PizzaItalian Sausage PizzaGarlic Bread
Insider Tip: Skip the weekend dinner rush when SSU students pack the place. Tuesday and Wednesday nights offer the best service and freshest ingredients.
2. Mary’s Pizza Shack – Rohnert Park
✨ Best for: Wine Country Classic
📍 Rohnert Park · ⭐ 3.5 · 464 reviews · $$
Mary's Pizza Shack has been feeding Sonoma County families since the 1950s, and their Rohnert Park outpost maintains that homestyle tradition. The thick-crust combo pizza arrives loaded with fresh mushrooms and bell peppers that actually taste like vegetables, not cardboard. Their ranch dressing is legendary among locals, and the salad bar still feels like a throwback to simpler times when iceberg lettuce wasn't controversial.
Must-Order:
Combo PizzaCaesar SaladChicken Wings
Insider Tip: The salad bar gets restocked around 11:30 AM and 5:30 PM, so time your visit accordingly for the crispest vegetables.
View Mary’s Pizza Shack – Rohnert Park →
3. Mountain Mike's Pizza
✨ Best for: Mountain-Sized Portions
📍 Rohnert Park · ⭐ 3.6 · 136 reviews · $$
Mountain Mike's doesn't mess around with portion sizes – their large pizzas require architectural engineering to fit through most doorways. The crust strikes a perfect balance between chewy and crispy, providing a sturdy foundation for their signature Everest pizza that's buried under an avalanche of toppings. The ranch here is cult-worthy, and the garlic bread could serve as a legitimate side dish for four people.
Must-Order:
Everest PizzaGarlic BreadRanch Dressing
Insider Tip: Order the large pizza even for two people – the leftover slices reheat better than most pizza places and make excellent breakfast.
4. Mountain Mike's Pizza
✨ Best for: Consistent Crowd-Pleaser
📍 Rohnert Park · ⭐ 3.5 · 135 reviews · $$
This second Mountain Mike's location serves as the neighborhood anchor for residents on the other side of town. Their McKinley pizza showcases thick-cut pepperoni and Italian sausage that doesn't skimp on the spice blend. The staff knows most customers by name and their usual orders, creating that small-town feel even within a chain restaurant setting. Their lunch buffet draws the local business crowd looking for reliable fuel.
Must-Order:
McKinley PizzaLunch BuffetPepperoni Rolls
Insider Tip: The lunch buffet runs until 2 PM on weekdays, but the best selection appears between noon and 1 PM when they refresh everything.
5. Pizza Guys
✨ Best for: Late-Night Champion
📍 Rohnert Park · ⭐ 4.3 · 40 reviews
Pizza Guys earns fierce loyalty from late-night diners and delivery devotees who appreciate consistency above all else. Their honey BBQ chicken pizza manages to balance sweet and savory without turning into dessert, while their garlic sticks arrive genuinely garlicky rather than just buttery. The ordering system is streamlined for efficiency, and they consistently deliver hot food faster than their competitors promise.
Must-Order:
Honey BBQ Chicken PizzaGarlic SticksBuffalo Wings
Insider Tip: They deliver until 2 AM on weekends, making them the go-to choice when other places have already closed their kitchens.
Tips for Finding Great Pizza in Rohnert Park
Avoid Peak Hours: Most pizza joints get slammed between 6-8 PM on weekends when families are ordering dinner. Call ahead or visit during off-peak times for better service.
Ask About Specials: Several local spots run weekday deals that aren't heavily advertised. Tuesday and Wednesday often feature the best discounts on large pizzas.
Check the Crust: Rohnert Park pizza places tend to excel at either thin or thick crust, rarely both. Ask what style they do best before ordering.
Consider Delivery Zones: Some restaurants have limited delivery areas within Rohnert Park. Check boundaries before assuming they'll deliver to your neighborhood.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
We ranked these spots based on consistency, local reputation, and value rather than just online ratings. Each restaurant was evaluated on food quality, service reliability, and their role in the community.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, reviews, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
