Sonoma County's pizza scene spans from brewpub classics to authentic Neapolitan gems. Between vineyard visits and farmers market runs, locals know where to find the perfect slice.
These ten spots earned their stripes through consistent quality and devoted followings. From Santa Rosa's bustling downtown to Yountville's wine tourist corridor, each serves pizza worth the drive.
📍 All 10 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- Russian River Brewing — Brewpub Pizza Perfection
- Wild Goat Bistro — Artisan Goat Paradise
- Pizzaleah — Windsor's Rising Star
- The Red Grape — Wine Country Comfort
- L’Oro Di Napoli — Authentic Neapolitan Gold
- Hector's Pizza — Petaluma's Pizza King
- Sal's Pizzeria — Cotati's Neighborhood Gem
- Ciccio — Yountville's Casual Champion
- Barley & Bine Beer Cafe — Beer Garden Bliss
- Gio's Pizza — Santa Rosa Classic
1. Russian River Brewing
✨ Best for: Brewpub Pizza Perfection
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.0 · 3794 reviews · $$
Russian River Brewing proves that great beer and great pizza are natural partners. Their wood-fired pies complement hoppy IPAs perfectly, with charred crusts that snap under the weight of house-made sausage and pepperoni. The brewpub atmosphere draws everyone from tech workers grabbing lunch to families celebrating Little League victories. Order at the bar, grab a Pliny if you're lucky, and settle in for pizza that tastes even better with their legendary ales.
Must-Order:
Pliny IPA PizzaPepperoni & SausageMargherita
Insider Tip: Arrive early for lunch to snag patio seating, and ask about beer and pizza pairing suggestions from the knowledgeable bartenders.
2. Wild Goat Bistro
✨ Best for: Artisan Goat Paradise
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.0 · 1162 reviews · $$
Wild Goat Bistro elevates pizza with ingredients that would make any wine country chef proud. Their house-made goat cheese appears on nearly every pie, paired with seasonal vegetables from local farms. The thin crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, while creative combinations like fig and prosciutto make this Petaluma favorite feel more bistro than pizzeria. Couples on date nights mix with families who appreciate the sophisticated yet approachable menu.
Must-Order:
Goat Cheese & FigProsciutto SpecialSeasonal Vegetable
Insider Tip: Call ahead for weekend reservations, especially during harvest season when wine country crowds discover this local treasure.
3. Pizzaleah
✨ Best for: Windsor's Rising Star
📍 Windsor · ⭐ 4.6 · 430 reviews · $$
Pizzaleah has become Windsor's worst-kept secret, drawing crowds who rave about owner Leah's perfectionist approach to pizza making. Each pie emerges from the oven with leopard-spotted crusts and perfectly balanced toppings. The small space fills quickly with locals who've discovered that this unassuming spot rivals anything in San Francisco. Expect bold flavor combinations and dough that's been fermenting for days, resulting in complex, tangy notes that elevate every bite.
Must-Order:
Signature Leah's SpecialPepperoni PerfectionSeasonal Creation
Insider Tip: Follow their social media for daily specials featuring seasonal ingredients, and prepare for a wait during peak dinner hours.
4. The Red Grape
✨ Best for: Wine Country Comfort
📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 4.0 · 984 reviews · $$
The Red Grape captures Sonoma's laid-back wine country vibe while serving pizzas that pair beautifully with their extensive local wine list. The outdoor patio fills with visitors fresh from tasting rooms, but locals know to come for the consistently excellent margherita and creative seasonal specials. The crust walks the line between Neapolitan and New York styles, substantial enough to support generous toppings without overwhelming delicate flavors. Perfect for unwinding after a day in the vineyards.
Must-Order:
MargheritaWine Country WhiteSeasonal Special
Insider Tip: The outdoor patio books up fast during wine season, so make reservations or arrive right at opening for the best seats.
5. L’Oro Di Napoli
✨ Best for: Authentic Neapolitan Gold
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.5 · 415 reviews · $$
L'Oro Di Napoli transports diners straight to southern Italy with pizzas that respect centuries-old traditions. The San Marzano tomatoes and imported buffalo mozzarella cost extra, but one bite proves the investment worthwhile. Their wood-burning oven reaches temperatures that create the signature charred bubbles and soft, pillowy centers that define authentic Neapolitan pizza. Italian expats and pizza purists make pilgrimages here, often leaving other Santa Rosa spots disappointed by comparison.
Must-Order:
Margherita DOCSan Marzano SpecialQuattro Stagioni
Insider Tip: Come for lunch to avoid evening crowds, and don't skip the imported Italian desserts that few other local spots can match.
6. Hector's Pizza
✨ Best for: Petaluma's Pizza King
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.6 · 337 reviews · $$
Hector's Pizza has earned legendary status among Petaluma locals through decades of consistent, no-nonsense pizza making. The family-run operation focuses on generous portions and classic combinations that satisfy without pretension. Their thick-crust pies arrive loaded with cheese and toppings, creating the kind of satisfying meal that fuels construction workers and feeds growing families. The pepperoni cups and curls properly, the cheese browns beautifully, and nobody leaves hungry from this old-school favorite.
Must-Order:
Supreme DeluxePepperoni ClassicItalian Sausage
Insider Tip: Order ahead for pickup during dinner rush, and ask about family-size options that offer the best value for larger groups.
7. Sal's Pizzeria
✨ Best for: Cotati's Neighborhood Gem
📍 Cotati · ⭐ 4.4 · 384 reviews · $$
Sal's Pizzeria proves that great pizza doesn't need a trendy location or Instagram-worthy decor. This Cotati institution focuses entirely on what matters: perfectly balanced sauce, quality cheese, and dough made fresh daily. The thin-crust New York style appeals to transplants missing East Coast pizza, while creative California combinations satisfy local tastes. College students and longtime residents create an unlikely mix of customers united by their appreciation for straightforward, delicious pizza.
Must-Order:
New York PepperoniSal's SpecialVeggie Supreme
Insider Tip: Cash payments get you a small discount, and the lunch portions are generous enough to share or save for later.
8. Ciccio
✨ Best for: Yountville's Casual Champion
Tripadvisor📍 Yountville · ⭐ 4.0 · 555 reviews · $$
Ciccio brings casual Italian charm to Yountville's high-end dining scene, offering pizza that satisfies without the pretension of neighboring Michelin-starred establishments. Their Margherita Pizza showcases San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, while the Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza balances salty meat with peppery greens. The Quattro Stagioni delivers four distinct flavors in perfect harmony. Families escaping fancy tasting room meals find comfort here, while couples enjoy intimate dinners that won't break the bank.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaProsciutto and Arugula PizzaQuattro Stagioni
Insider Tip: Visit during off-peak hours to avoid the dinner rush, as this popular spot can get quite busy with both locals and Wine Country visitors.
9. Barley & Bine Beer Cafe
✨ Best for: Beer Garden Bliss
Tripadvisor📍 Windsor · ⭐ 4.6 · 232 reviews · $$
Barley & Bine Beer Cafe combines craft beer expertise with surprisingly excellent pizza, creating Windsor's favorite spot for casual nights out. Their beer-friendly pies feature bold flavors that stand up to hoppy IPAs and rich stouts. The industrial-chic space fills with beer enthusiasts who've discovered that the kitchen takes pizza as seriously as the bar takes brewing. Expect creative toppings and perfectly charred crusts that make this beer cafe a legitimate pizza destination, not just a place with decent food.
Must-Order:
Craft Beer Pairing PizzaHoppy IPA SpecialSeasonal Tap Pizza
Insider Tip: Check their tap list before ordering pizza – the staff excels at suggesting beer pairings that elevate both the pizza and the brew.
View Barley & Bine Beer Cafe →
10. Gio's Pizza
✨ Best for: Santa Rosa Classic
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.2 · 388 reviews · $$
Gio's Pizza serves Santa Rosa with the kind of reliable, family-friendly pizza that builds lasting neighborhoods relationships. Three generations of customers have grown up on their cheese-heavy pies and crispy thin crusts. The modest storefront doesn't win beauty contests, but the pizza wins hearts through consistent execution and generous portions. Soccer teams celebrate victories here, families grab dinner before school events, and anyone seeking comfort food without surprises finds exactly what they're craving.
Must-Order:
Three Cheese ClassicGio's SpecialPepperoni Traditional
Insider Tip: Weekend evenings get busy with families, so arrive early or call ahead to check wait times for the most popular hours.
Tips for Finding Great Pizza in Wine Country
Time It Right: Avoid the 6-8pm dinner rush when possible, especially during harvest season when tourist crowds peak. Many spots offer the same great pizza with shorter waits during lunch hours.
Embrace Local Ingredients: The best Sonoma County pizzas feature local goat cheese, seasonal vegetables, and wine country-inspired toppings. Don't stick to basic pepperoni when creative combinations showcase regional flavors.
Consider the Setting: Many pizza spots offer outdoor seating perfect for the temperate climate. Call ahead about patio availability, especially during beautiful weather when everyone wants to dine al fresco.
Pair Thoughtfully: Local breweries and wine-focused pizza spots excel at beverage pairings. Ask servers for recommendations that complement both the pizza flavors and the relaxed wine country atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
Our rankings blend customer ratings, review volume, and local word-of-mouth recommendations gathered from longtime Sonoma County residents. We prioritized consistent quality and authentic local following over tourist popularity alone.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, reviews, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
