Santa Rosa's pizza scene runs deeper than tourist maps suggest. From brewery pies paired with local hops to authentic Neapolitan ovens, wine country has quietly become a pizza destination.
These ten spots earned their place through consistent quality and devoted local followings. Each offers something different, whether it's perfect crust, creative toppings, or that neighborhood vibe every pizza lover craves.
📍 All 10 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- Russian River Brewing — Brewery Pizza Excellence
- L’Oro Di Napoli — Neapolitan Gold Standard
- Gio's Pizza — Local Family Favorite
- Mombo's Pizza — No-Frills Value Champion
- NY Pie — Consistent Neighborhood Staple
- Pizza Guys — Budget-Friendly Reliable
- Joey's Original Pizza — Original Recipe Tradition
- Tomatina — Italian Authenticity Delivered
- Gio's Pizza – Industrial Drive — Hidden Industrial Gem
- Papa Murphy's — Take-and-Bake Convenience
1. Russian River Brewing
✨ Best for: Brewery Pizza Excellence
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.0 · 3794 reviews · $$
Russian River Brewing proves that breweries can nail pizza just as well as beer. Their wood-fired pies arrive bubbling with perfectly charred crusts that complement their famous Pliny perfectly. The space buzzes with locals who know that ordering a flight with your pizza isn't just acceptable—it's mandatory. The kitchen doesn't mess around with gimmicky toppings, focusing instead on quality ingredients that let both the beer and pizza shine. Weekend waits are legendary, but the combination of exceptional brews and solid pies makes it worth the hassle.
Must-Order:
Wood-Fired MargheritaPepperoni PizzaLocal IPA Flight
Insider Tip: Arrive early on weekends or prepare for lengthy waits—the beer helps pass the time, but tables fill fast during peak hours.
2. L’Oro Di Napoli
✨ Best for: Neapolitan Gold Standard
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.5 · 415 reviews · $$
L'Oro Di Napoli transports you straight to Italy without the passport hassle. Their Neapolitan-style pizzas emerge from a blazing hot oven with leopard-spotted crusts and centers that wobble just right. The dough ferments for days, creating those signature airy bubbles that serious pizza nerds obsess over. Owner-operated with genuine Italian pride, every pie feels personal. The margherita here sets the standard—San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil that actually tastes like something. This isn't fast food; it's edible art that happens to be pizza-shaped.
Must-Order:
Neapolitan MargheritaMarinara PizzaProsciutto Arugula
Insider Tip: Call ahead for weekend reservations, and don't skip the appetizers while you wait for your perfectly timed Neapolitan pies to emerge from the oven.
3. Gio's Pizza
✨ Best for: Local Family Favorite
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.2 · 388 reviews · $$
Gio's Pizza has mastered that perfect balance between neighborhood joint and destination spot. Their New York-style slices are generous enough to satisfy wine country appetites, with a crust that's crispy outside and chewy inside. The pepperoni cups and curls when it hits the oven heat, creating those little grease pools that pizza purists crave. Families pack the checkered-tablecloth dining room, while solo diners belly up to the counter for a quick slice and beer. It's the kind of place where servers remember your order and kids beg to come back.
Must-Order:
New York PepperoniSausage PizzaGarlic Knots
Insider Tip: Visit during weekday lunch for quicker service and the same great pizza without the dinner rush crowds that pack this family favorite.
4. Mombo's Pizza
✨ Best for: No-Frills Value Champion
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.9 · 509 reviews · $
Mombo's Pizza delivers exactly what you hope for in a budget pizza spot—generous portions, reliable flavors, and prices that don't hurt. Their thick crust carries serious weight, loaded with enough cheese and toppings to qualify as a full meal. The sauce leans sweet, appealing to kids and adults who prefer their pizza without too much tang. During lunch, construction workers and office staff mix over shared appreciation for honest pizza at honest prices. Nothing fancy happens here, but sometimes simple and satisfying beats trendy every time.
Must-Order:
Thick Crust ComboPepperoni SpecialCheese Pizza
Insider Tip: Order online during busy periods to skip the wait, and ask about daily specials that aren't always advertised on the regular menu.
5. NY Pie
✨ Best for: Consistent Neighborhood Staple
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.4 · 720 reviews · $$
NY Pie has weathered decades of Santa Rosa dining trends by sticking to what works. Their margherita pizza showcases a thin crust that snaps when you fold it, topped with bright tomato sauce and mozzarella that stretches for days. The chicken parmigiana brings Italian-American comfort food vibes, while their Caesar salad provides a fresh contrast to all that cheese. Families treat this place like their personal kitchen, with servers who genuinely care about getting your order right. The dining room feels lived-in rather than designed, which perfectly suits its loyal neighborhood crowd.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaChicken ParmigianaCaesar Salad
Insider Tip: Hit them during weekday lunch hours to avoid dinner rush waits—the staff moves faster and you'll get the same quality with better service.
6. Pizza Guys
✨ Best for: Budget-Friendly Reliable
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.9 · 300 reviews · $
Pizza Guys keeps things refreshingly straightforward in a town full of artisanal everything. Their hand-tossed pies arrive hot and loaded, with crusts that hit that sweet spot between crispy and chewy. The pepperoni pizza satisfies without pretense, while their combination pies pile on the toppings without skimping. College students and families appreciate the generous portions and wallet-friendly prices. The storefront location might not win beauty contests, but the pizza speaks for itself. Sometimes you just want reliable pizza without the fuss, and Pizza Guys delivers exactly that promise.
Must-Order:
Hand-Tossed PepperoniCombination PizzaCheese Bread
Insider Tip: Check for weekday lunch deals and order extra cheese if you like it loaded—they're generous with toppings when you ask nicely.
7. Joey's Original Pizza
✨ Best for: Original Recipe Tradition
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.5 · 381 reviews · $$
Joey's Original Pizza has been slinging pies since before farm-to-table became a buzzword. Their hand-stretched dough creates a medium-thick crust that holds up to serious topping loads without getting soggy. The sausage pizza showcases chunks of well-seasoned meat that taste like they actually came from local sources. Old-school red vinyl booths and wood paneling create that authentic pizzeria atmosphere that newer spots try to manufacture. The lunch crowd includes plenty of regulars who've been coming here for years, drawn by consistent quality and zero attitude.
Must-Order:
Sausage PizzaPepperoni ClassicItalian Sub
Insider Tip: Lunch service moves fastest, and the pizza tastes exactly the same as dinner without the weekend wait times that can stretch past an hour.
8. Tomatina
✨ Best for: Italian Authenticity Delivered
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.3 · 399 reviews · $$
Tomatina brings Italian soul to Santa Rosa with pizzas that taste like they emerged from a Roman neighborhood joint. Their margherita pizza balances sweet tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil with the kind of precision that comes from genuine understanding. The Caesar salad provides a crisp counterpoint to rich pies, while penne arrabbiata satisfies pasta cravings with proper heat. Families with kids feel welcome here, thanks to staff who actually enjoy their jobs. The casual atmosphere encourages lingering over wine and conversation, making it perfect for those nights when nobody wants to rush home.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaCaesar SaladPenne Arrabbiata
Insider Tip: Weekday lunch visits offer a more relaxed experience with the same great food—dinner service can get hectic with families and larger groups.
9. Gio's Pizza – Industrial Drive
✨ Best for: Hidden Industrial Gem
📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 4.5 · 30 reviews
Gio's Pizza on Industrial Drive operates like Santa Rosa's best-kept pizza secret. This smaller location focuses on quality over quantity, turning out pies with the same care as their main spot but with shorter waits. The intimate space fills with locals who discovered this hidden location and never looked back. Their specialty pizzas showcase creative combinations that work because someone in the kitchen actually thinks about flavor balance. The limited seating means most orders go home, but grabbing a slice at the counter while you wait gives you front-row seats to pizza-making artistry.
Must-Order:
Specialty ComboClassic MargheritaWhite Pizza
Insider Tip: This location stays quieter than the main spot, making it perfect for quick pickups or when you want to actually watch the pizza-making process.
View Gio's Pizza – Industrial Drive →
10. Papa Murphy's
✨ Best for: Take-and-Bake Convenience
Tripadvisor📍 Santa Rosa · ⭐ 3.5 · 56 reviews · $
Papa Murphy's perfects the take-and-bake concept for families who want fresh pizza on their own timeline. Their pepperoni pizza loads up with quality ingredients that bake beautifully in your home oven, while the supreme pizza satisfies those who want everything on top. The meat lovers option brings serious protein power for hearty appetites. Staff actually takes pride in building your pizza right, creating combinations that hold together during transport and baking. For busy families, this spot eliminates delivery timing stress while delivering pizza that tastes better than most delivery chains could manage.
Must-Order:
Pepperoni PizzaSupreme PizzaMeat Lovers Pizza
Insider Tip: Call ahead during dinner rush to have your pizza ready for pickup—saves significant time on busy weeknights when everyone's ordering take-and-bake.
Tips for Finding Great Pizza in Santa Rosa
Time Your Visit: Weekday lunches offer the best service and shortest waits at most spots. Weekend dinners require patience or reservations.
Ask About Specials: Many places run daily deals that aren't advertised online. Local favorites often have off-menu items for regular customers.
Consider the Pairing: Santa Rosa's pizza spots often excel at beer and wine pairings. Ask servers for recommendations that complement your pie choice.
Check Multiple Locations: Some pizza chains have multiple Santa Rosa locations with different vibes and wait times. The smaller spots sometimes offer better service.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
These rankings combine customer review data, local word-of-mouth recommendations, and consistency over time. We weighted heavily toward spots that maintain quality during busy periods and have earned devoted local followings rather than just tourist traffic.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, reviews, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
