Psychic Pie

Psychic Pie has carved out a unique niche in Sebastopol’s vibrant culinary scene by combining artisanal pizza craft with fresh, locally-sourced salads that celebrate Sonoma County’s agricultural bounty. This beloved neighborhood gem elevates casual dining with house-made doughs, seasonal ingredients, and creative combinations that reflect the area’s farm-to-table philosophy.

The menu strikes a perfect balance between comfort and creativity, featuring wood-fired pizzas with inventive toppings like local goat cheese, heirloom tomatoes, and house-cured meats alongside expansive salad offerings that showcase whatever’s freshest from nearby farms. Their signature pies blend traditional techniques with Wine Country flair, while the salad selection ranges from classic Caesar to seasonal creations featuring ingredients like roasted beets, candied walnuts, and locally-produced cheeses.

The atmosphere captures Sebastopol’s laid-back, artistic spirit with rustic wooden tables, local artwork adorning exposed brick walls, and an open kitchen where you can watch pizza makers work their magic. Large windows flood the space with natural light during the day, while warm Edison bulb lighting creates an intimate ambiance for evening dining. The casual yet thoughtful design makes it equally suitable for family dinners or romantic dates.

Whether you’re a local seeking your neighborhood go-to or a Wine Country visitor looking for authentic flavors beyond the vineyard, Psychic Pie delivers an experience that’s both satisfying and memorable. The combination of exceptional food quality, reasonable prices, and genuine hospitality makes it a standout choice in a region known for culinary excellence.