Sonoma's pizza scene stretches far beyond tourist traps, with wood-fired ovens and family-run joints serving up pies that complement the valley's legendary wine culture. From crispy-crust classics to innovative toppings, these spots know how to satisfy.
We've ranked these six pizzerias based on local loyalty, consistency, and that magical combination of crust, sauce, and cheese that keeps Sonoma residents coming back. Each offers something different for this wine country community.
📍 All 6 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- The Red Grape — Wine Country Classic
- Mary's Pizza Shack — Family Institution Reliability
- Il Fuoco — Artisan Fire Excellence
- Mary's Pizza Shack — Comfort Food Champion
- Slice Shack By Mary’s — Quick Slice Haven
- Kashaya's Portable Wood fired Pizza — Mobile Wood-Fired Magic
1. The Red Grape
✨ Best for: Wine Country Classic
📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 4.0 · 984 reviews · $$
The Red Grape strikes the perfect balance between wine country sophistication and neighborhood comfort. Their crusts achieve that coveted crispy-yet-chewy texture, topped with quality ingredients that don't compete with your Pinot Noir. The dining room buzzes with a mix of vineyard workers grabbing late lunch and couples sharing pies before hitting the tasting rooms. Service moves at an unhurried Sonoma pace, which means you can actually taste your food.
Must-Order:
Pepperoni PizzaArugula SaladHouse Red Wine
Insider Tip: Arrive before 6 PM on weekends to snag a table without waiting, and ask about their wine pairings with local bottles.
2. Mary's Pizza Shack
✨ Best for: Family Institution Reliability
Tripadvisor📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 3.4 · 516 reviews · $$
Mary's Pizza Shack represents pure Sonoma nostalgia – the kind of place where three generations gather around red checkered tablecloths. Their Margherita Pizza showcases simple perfection with fresh mozzarella and bright tomato sauce, while the Caesar Salad arrives crisp and garlicky. The Spaghetti and Meatballs could feed a small vineyard crew. It's not fancy, but it's exactly what families crave after a long day exploring wine country.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaSpaghetti and MeatballsCaesar Salad
Insider Tip: Visit during weekday lunch hours to avoid the dinner rush and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience with the freshest pizzas.
3. Il Fuoco
✨ Best for: Artisan Fire Excellence
📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 4.2 · 112 reviews · $$
Il Fuoco elevates pizza to an art form with their blazing wood-fired oven that reaches temperatures most home cooks can only dream of. The result is pizza with leopard-spotted crusts and toppings that taste like they were kissed by flames. This is where Sonoma's restaurant industry workers eat on their nights off – always a good sign. The intimate space fills quickly with serious food lovers who appreciate technique as much as taste.
Must-Order:
Wood-Fired MargheritaProsciutto and ArugulaSeasonal Special
Insider Tip: Make a reservation for dinner service since the intimate space fills up fast, especially on Friday and Saturday nights.
4. Mary's Pizza Shack
✨ Best for: Comfort Food Champion
Tripadvisor📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 3.2 · 211 reviews · $$
This second Mary's location doubles down on comfort food excellence, serving Margherita Pizza alongside hearty Chicken Parmigiana that could satisfy the hungriest harvest worker. Their Caesar Salad provides the perfect acidic counterpoint to rich, cheesy pies. The staff treats regulars like extended family, remembering orders and asking about the kids. It's the kind of reliable neighborhood spot that makes Sonoma feel like a real community, not just a tourist destination.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaChicken ParmigianaCaesar Salad
Insider Tip: Visit during weeknight hours to avoid the weekend rush and ensure the freshest pizzas straight from the oven.
5. Slice Shack By Mary’s
✨ Best for: Quick Slice Haven
📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 3.7 · 74 reviews · $
Slice Shack By Mary's strips away the sit-down formality for grab-and-go convenience without sacrificing quality. Perfect for when you need sustenance between winery visits but don't want to commit to a full meal. The counter service moves quickly, and the pizza-by-the-slice approach lets you sample different styles. It's become the unofficial lunch spot for local shop workers and wine industry folks on tight schedules.
Must-Order:
Pepperoni SliceCombo SliceGarlic Knots
Insider Tip: Check their daily specials board for unique slice combinations that aren't on the regular menu.
6. Kashaya's Portable Wood fired Pizza
✨ Best for: Mobile Wood-Fired Magic
📍 Sonoma · ⭐ 4.7 · 21 reviews · $$
Kashaya's brings the ancient art of wood-fired pizza directly to you with their mobile operation that sets up at farmers markets and private events. The portable oven reaches scorching temperatures that create perfectly charred crusts in minutes. Owner-operators who clearly live and breathe pizza craft each pie with obsessive attention to detail. Finding them requires some sleuthing, but the reward is pizza that rivals any brick-and-mortar establishment.
Must-Order:
Wood-Fired MargheritaSeasonal VegetablePepperoni Special
Insider Tip: Follow their social media to track locations and arrival times since they move between different venues throughout the week.
View Kashaya's Portable Wood fired Pizza →
Tips for Finding Great Pizza in Sonoma
Timing Matters Most: Visit during off-peak hours for better service and fresher pies. Most places get slammed during weekend dinner rushes.
Wood-Fired Worth Waiting: Pizzas from wood-fired ovens take longer but deliver superior flavor and texture. The char and smokiness can't be replicated in regular ovens.
Local Wine Pairings: Many spots offer local wine selections that complement their pizzas perfectly. Don't overlook these curated pairings when dining in wine country.
Family Style Strategy: Order different styles to share since Sonoma's generous portions and diverse toppings make sampling multiple pies more satisfying than sticking to one.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
We selected these six pizzerias based on consistent local recommendations, online review patterns, and repeat customer loyalty over multiple years. Our rankings consider both food quality and the overall dining experience that keeps Sonoma residents returning regularly.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, reviews, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
