Petaluma's pizza scene has quietly become one of Sonoma County's most diverse, spanning everything from wood-fired bistro pies to old-school parlor classics. The river town's appetite for quality dough runs deep.
These seven spots represent the full spectrum of what makes Petaluma pizza special—from farm-to-table ingredients sourced from surrounding dairy country to family recipes perfected over decades. Each brings something different to the table.
📍 All 7 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- Wild Goat Bistro — Upscale Bistro Elegance
- Hector's Pizza — Neighborhood Favorite Champion
- Lunchette — Artisanal Small-Batch Perfection
- Pizza Guys — Reliable Chain Comfort
- Acre Pizza — Farm-Fresh Local Focus
- Pinky's Pizza Parlor — Classic Parlor Vibes
- Fregene's Pizza — Budget-Friendly Authenticity
1. Wild Goat Bistro
✨ Best for: Upscale Bistro Elegance
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.0 · 1162 reviews · $$
Wild Goat Bistro elevates pizza beyond casual dining with sophisticated combinations that showcase Sonoma County ingredients. The prosciutto and fig pizza arrives with paper-thin crust that crackles under the knife, topped with creamy burrata and a drizzle of local honey. Wine country professionals and date-night couples fill the modern dining room, where servers know their way around the extensive wine list. The kitchen doesn't shy away from bold flavors—expect house-made sausage, roasted seasonal vegetables, and artisanal cheeses that change with the harvest calendar.
Must-Order:
Prosciutto & Fig PizzaBurrata MargheritaWild Mushroom Pizza
Insider Tip: Make reservations for dinner service, especially on weekends when the wine country crowd descends. The bar serves excellent cocktails while you wait.
2. Hector's Pizza
✨ Best for: Neighborhood Favorite Champion
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.6 · 337 reviews · $$
Hector's Pizza has earned its reputation through consistent execution and generous portions that keep families coming back weekly. The pepperoni cups up beautifully under high heat, creating little pools of spiced oil across a crust that strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crisp. Local youth soccer teams celebrate victories here, while parents appreciate the reasonable prices and reliable quality. The combination pizza loads on Italian sausage, bell peppers, and mushrooms with the kind of abundance that makes leftovers a given.
Must-Order:
Combination PizzaPepperoni PizzaItalian Sausage Pizza
Insider Tip: Order ahead by phone during Little League season—the place gets packed with celebrating teams. Their lunch specials offer the same quality at lower prices.
3. Lunchette
✨ Best for: Artisanal Small-Batch Perfection
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.7 · 106 reviews · $$
Lunchette operates like pizza's answer to a specialty coffee shop—small batches, carefully sourced ingredients, and an obsessive attention to detail that shows in every bite. The sourdough crust ferments for days, developing complex flavors that pair beautifully with house-made mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes. Afternoon crowds include local chefs on their days off and food-savvy locals who don't mind waiting for something special. Each pizza emerges from the oven as a small work of art, with toppings arranged with almost architectural precision.
Must-Order:
Sourdough MargheritaSeasonal Vegetable PizzaHouse-Made Sausage Pizza
Insider Tip: Visit during weekday lunch hours when the chef has more time to perfect each pizza. Weekend rushes can compromise their usually impeccable attention to detail.
4. Pizza Guys
✨ Best for: Reliable Chain Comfort
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 3.8 · 160 reviews · $$
Pizza Guys delivers exactly what the name promises—straightforward pizza without pretension, perfect for feeding hungry teenagers or satisfying late-night cravings. The crust leans thick and doughy, providing a substantial base for generous amounts of cheese and toppings. Families ordering delivery know they'll get consistent results, even if the experience won't win culinary awards. The meat lovers pizza piles on pepperoni, sausage, and ham with the kind of abundance that makes nutritionists weep but satisfies anyone seeking pure indulgence.
Must-Order:
Meat Lovers PizzaSupreme PizzaPepperoni Pizza
Insider Tip: Stick to their classic combinations rather than custom orders—their strength lies in execution, not creativity. Delivery is more reliable than pickup during busy periods.
5. Acre Pizza
✨ Best for: Farm-Fresh Local Focus
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 3.8 · 152 reviews · $$
Acre Pizza embraces Petaluma's agricultural heritage with a menu that changes based on what's growing locally, from spring asparagus to autumn squash. The wood-fired oven imparts a subtle smokiness that complements fresh mozzarella and vegetables picked that morning from nearby farms. Young professionals and empty nesters appreciate the seasonal approach, even when limited options mean their favorite pizza might disappear until next year. The margherita showcases the kitchen's restraint—just tomato, cheese, and basil, but each component singing in perfect harmony.
Must-Order:
Seasonal Farm PizzaWood-Fired MargheritaLocal Vegetable Pizza
Insider Tip: Check their social media for seasonal menu updates before visiting. The best pizzas often feature ingredients available for just a few weeks each year.
6. Pinky's Pizza Parlor
✨ Best for: Classic Parlor Vibes
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 3.7 · 167 reviews · $$
Pinky's Pizza Parlor preserves the kind of neighborhood pizza joint that defined American childhood, complete with red checkered tablecloths and a jukebox that still plays Sinatra. The thin crust arrives slightly charred around the edges, supporting a layer of tangy sauce and cheese that stretches dramatically with each slice. Three generations of families gather in the worn booths, sharing stories over pitchers of soda and extra-large combinations. The atmosphere feels frozen in time, when pizza parlors served as community gathering spots rather than just food vendors.
Must-Order:
Combination PizzaThin Crust PepperoniCheese Pizza
Insider Tip: Arrive early for dinner to snag one of the original booths with the best jukebox access. The lunch crowd tends to be quieter if you prefer conversation.
7. Fregene's Pizza
✨ Best for: Budget-Friendly Authenticity
📍 Petaluma · ⭐ 4.4 · 73 reviews · $
Fregene's Pizza proves that great food doesn't require high prices, serving authentic Italian-style pies that would make nonna proud. The crust stays thin and leopard-spotted from the blazing oven, while the sauce maintains that perfect balance of sweet and acidic that defines real Italian pizza. Locals in the know stop by for lunch specials that cost less than most coffee drinks elsewhere. The margherita pizza showcases technique over flashy toppings—San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil leaves that wilt perfectly in the residual heat.
Must-Order:
Margherita PizzaItalian Sausage PizzaPepperoni Pizza
Insider Tip: Come for lunch when prices drop significantly on the same quality pizzas. The afternoon lull means faster service and often a chat with the owner.
Tips for Finding Great Pizza in Petaluma
Embrace Seasonal Menus: Several spots change offerings based on local harvests. Spring asparagus and fall squash pizzas showcase Petaluma's agricultural bounty at its peak.
Consider Lunch Timing: Many pizzerias offer better value and less crowded dining during lunch hours. You'll get the same quality with more attentive service and lower prices.
Call Ahead Weekends: Friday and Saturday nights bring wine country visitors and local families together. Reservations or advance orders prevent long waits at popular spots.
Try Local Ingredients: Petaluma's dairy heritage means exceptional cheese options. Look for pizzas featuring local mozzarella, goat cheese, or other Sonoma County specialties.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
We selected these pizzerias based on consistent quality, local reputation, and unique contributions to Petaluma's dining scene. Our rankings consider both online ratings and word-of-mouth recommendations from long-time residents.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, reviews, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
